Monday, 1 January 2001

Task 2.5 Comparison of Sequences (600 words)

The Longest Day - Saving Private Ryan Beach scene






I have chosen to compare both 'beach scenes' from 'the longest day' and 'saving private ryan.' Firstly both of the films were made in two different time periods, hence the difference in technological advances such as colour and camera range. In 'saving private ryan' their are a number of shots in which could not have been achieved during the making of 'the longest day' due to this difference in time. A example of this could be when the camera dips in and out of the water as 'Tom Hanks' storms the beach, with occasional reference to other characters deaths under the water. Another difference they share is that in 'saving private ryan' the directors choose to physically narrate the sequence through main character 'Tom Hanks,' whereas the longest day has a number of characters in which the camera follow equally. 'Saving private ryan' also uses other advances in time to present gore and numerous explosions. In one section of the sequence a man is injured on the floor with organs hanging from his body while still alive and unreachable. This would have been difficult for 'the longest day' to achieve as it would not have been acceptable to show in film when it was made,(1963.) Furthermore artificial explosions and gunshots are also shown to be very realistic and deadly through the use of special effects however the creators of 'the longest day' were unable to do so due to lack of resources and knowledge in this period. Both films present a different historical context as well due to the time at which it was made. 'The longest yard' was made in 1963 which is a mere 18 years since the war ended and therefore they have a very post war attitude when filming. Examples of this include men dying as gentlemen on a minor scale, whereas the modern attitude to events was that they wanted to show exactly how events unfolded. A total disregard for life, men died in fear and in some cases unpleasantly. This theme tends to continue as in 'saving private ryan' the storming of the beach appears much more difficult and takes longer with more casualties, whereas 'the longest day' seems to take a matter of minutes which is very unrealistic. Both sequences despite their differences also share similar aspects such as, setting and costume. Both settings are very similar as both include a open beach with tank blocks and the opposition in positions of power. As for costume, both the weapons and the dress of characters are historically accurate and not dissimilar from each other. In conclusion both films are attempting to portray the same events in very different ways depending on the time at which they were made. 'The longest day' takes a rather post war attitude, with successes in set and costume. Although 'saving private ryan' takes naturally a more modern approach with use of cgi and technological advances to recreate a number of shots, explosions and gore of characters fearful death.

No comments:

Post a Comment